You're in Cakes & Pies

Need a Personal Shopper?

Subscribe to
Bizrate emails for the hottest
deals & products
,
PLUS a chance to

WIN $25

sign me up!

New winners chosen weekly.
No purchase necessary.

Best Seller
Holiday Bakery Tray - Ultimate

Holiday Bakery Tray - Ultimate

Take your holiday celebration to the next level with this bountiful array of bakery favorites. We've included goodies like moist fruitcake, our classic cinnamon swirl, sweet chocolate baklava, festive holiday cookies, and much more, so there's plenty... ... more

Holiday Bakery Tray - Ultimate

Take your holiday celebration to the next level with this bountiful array of bakery favorites. We've included goodies like moist fruitcake, our classic cinnamon swirl, sweet chocolate baklava, festive holiday cookies, and much more, so there's plenty...

$199.99

go to store
Signature New York-Style Cheesecake

Signature New York-Style Cheesecake

The union of style and simplicity, our signature cheesecake combines a sophisticated New York–style recipe with traditional touches like a crumbled graham cracker crust. This classic cheesecake has a silky texture and a rich, sweet flavor that pairs... ... more

Signature New York-Style Cheesecake

The union of style and simplicity, our signature cheesecake combines a sophisticated New York–style recipe with traditional touches like a crumbled graham cracker crust. This classic cheesecake has a silky texture and a rich, sweet flavor that pairs...

$34.99

go to store
Best Seller
Traditional Fruitcake

Traditional Fruitcake

Made with generous scoops of raisins, walnuts, cherries, and pineapple, our Traditional Fruitcake is sweetened with real molasses and delicately spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and a touch of ginger. Perfect as a gift or for your own celebration, this... ... more

Traditional Fruitcake

Made with generous scoops of raisins, walnuts, cherries, and pineapple, our Traditional Fruitcake is sweetened with real molasses and delicately spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and a touch of ginger. Perfect as a gift or for your own celebration, this...

$19.99

go to store
Traditional Fruitcake - 2 Pounds

Traditional Fruitcake - 2 Pounds

Our special fruitcake recipe, which calls for delectable candied fruit and premium nuts, results in dense, delicious fruitcake that's hard to resist. We mix it in small batches right here in our bakery and deliver it in a noteworthy keepsake tin.... ... more

Traditional Fruitcake - 2 Pounds

Our special fruitcake recipe, which calls for delectable candied fruit and premium nuts, results in dense, delicious fruitcake that's hard to resist. We mix it in small batches right here in our bakery and deliver it in a noteworthy keepsake tin....

$29.99

go to store
Cushman's™ Honeybell Cheesecake

Cushman's™ Honeybell Cheesecake

A fruity spin on a classic, the Cushman's HoneyBell Cheesecake is a delicious and creamy dessert for anyone who enjoys sweet citrus desserts. Made according to a traditional New York-style recipe, this citrus cheesecake is filled with pieces of juicy... ... more

Cushman's™ Honeybell Cheesecake

A fruity spin on a classic, the Cushman's HoneyBell Cheesecake is a delicious and creamy dessert for anyone who enjoys sweet citrus desserts. Made according to a traditional New York-style recipe, this citrus cheesecake is filled with pieces of juicy...

$49.99

go to store